Carey Bay mortgage brokers

Learn about buying a house in Carey Bay, see historical property data and start your home loan application today

What's it like to live in Carey Bay?

A small waterside suburb, the secret of Carey Bay is slowly becoming known to the world. If you’re looking for a quiet spot where you can watch the sunrise over the lake from your home, this might be for you. 

Historical property values in Carey Bay (2283)

Median Carey Bay home

  • Sale price: $1,177,500 (April 2026)
  • Sale price: $840,000 (April 2024)
  • Rental price: $655 p/w (April 2026)
  • Rental price: $550 p/w (April 2024)

Median Carey Bay unit

  • Sale price: $933,000 (April 2026)
  • Sale price: $705,000 (April 2024)
  • Rental price: $675 p/w (April 2026)
  • Rental price: $495 p/w (April 2024)

* All figures taken from realestate.com.au

Carey Bay features

Formerly home to a zoo and a famous lion who could be heard roaring across the lake in Belmont, Cary Bay has settled down into a quiet community spot by the water.  

With a population less than 1000, you’ll quickly learn who your neighbours are. This friendly suburb lives life at a relaxed pace, enjoying the tranquillity of the water. 

While Toronto is just a short drive away, there’s a small shopping centre in Carey Bay for all the essentials – a supermarket, bottle shop, cafe and the regulars you’d expect. 

As well as the natural attraction of the lake, Carey Bay has a couple of small reserves for nature lovers. Yarul Reserve is right on the water, giving you the best of both worlds and a great spot for a picnic. 

Sunset over the lake at Carey Bay near Toronto, NSW.

© Visit NSW

Distance to closest...

  • Beach: 21.5km (Dudley)
  • National park: 18.4km (Sugarloaf)
  • Charlestown: 18.5km
  • Hospital: 20.1km (John Hunter Hospital)
  • Trains: 6.0km (Fassifern Station)
  • Shops: 1.7km (Toronto)

Our Lake Macquarie mortgage brokers

Brad East, Managing Director.

BRAD EAST
Managing Director

Brad founded Wisebuy in 2015 and hasn’t looked back since. He loves helping his clients achieve their dreams.

Learn more
Sarah Taylor, Broker Associate.

SARAH TAYLOR
Mortgage Broker

Whether you’re buying your first home, refinancing or investing, Sarah’s here to make the process smooth and hassle-free.

Learn more
Evie Marshall, Mortgage Broker.

EVIE MARSHALL
Mortgage Broker

Looking to buy in this area? Call our Lake Macquarie mortgage brokers on (02) 49 614 985 or answer a few questions below and we’ll be in touch. 

1
Service Selection
2
Service-Specific Questions
3
Personal Information
4
Verification
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

What are you looking to purchase?

What Are You Looking To Do?
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Hey there, Let’s start by selecting what you are wanting to do.

Continue
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Now we just need to know your existing loan details so that we can try and save you some money each month.

Continue
Are you wanting to purchase or refinance?
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Perfect, let’s gather your existing loan details so we can see how much you could save.

shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Perfect, let’s gather your existing loan details so we can see how much you could save.

Continue
Is your SMSF already established?
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Let us know if your SMSF is already established. If not, we can help you get this sorted.

What type of property are you looking to invest in?
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

What kind of property are you wanting to invest in?

Continue
What kind of property are you looking to purchase?
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

What kind of property are you wanting to purchase?

shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Hit the submit button to find out if you’re eligible for a loan.

Proceed
I consent to the collection and use of my information as per the Privacy Policy(Required)
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

Great, we just need some basic information so we know who we are talking to. Our systems are 100% secure and we respect your privacy.

Continue

Verify your phone number

Please enter the 4 digit code sent to your phone
Haven’t received it. Resend a new code.
shutterstock 294130694 edited scaled

We have some great options waiting for you.

Submit
Need Help?
02 4961 4985

Learn more about the suburbs of Lake Macquarie

  • Fishing Point
  • Floraville
  • Freemans Waterhole
  • Garden Suburb
  • Gateshead
  • Glendale
  • Highfields
  • Hillsborough
  • Holmesville
  • Jewells
  • Kahibah
  • Kilaben Bay
  • Killingworth
  • Kotara South
  • Lakelands
  • Little Pelican
  • Macquarie Hills
  • Mandalong
  • Marks Point
  • Marmong Point
  • Martinsville
  • Mirrabooka
  • Moonee
  • Morisset Park
  • Morisset
  • Mount Hutton
  • Murrays Beach
  • Myuna Bay
  • New Lambton Heights
  • Nords Wharf
  • Pelican
  • Pinny Beach
  • Rankin Park
  • Rathmines
  • Redhead
  • Ryhope
  • Seahampton
  • Silverwater

See our full list of Lake Macquarie suburbs here.